Tuesday, 2nd December 2008

GP Opinion

Safety now second-best

A FEW short months before the schools at Les Nicolles are due to open and the war of words between two senior States departments over access and - more crucially - child safety has actually intensified.

What is happening is rather unedifying and, as is the way, ends up reflecting badly on government as a whole.

Islanders will see the situation rather simply. The States decided to put a huge school in an area serviced by one of the most dangerous roads in the island for pedestrians.

It did so knowing that a large number of children would want to walk or cycle to their new school. That meant ensuring measures were put in place so that they could do so.

Yet six months from the schools going live, parents and taxpayers are treated to the spectacle of Environment and Education slugging it out over what is the best way of ensuring that youngsters are not hurt, maimed or actually killed en route to or from what should be a building everyone can take pride in but which is now dominated by safety issues.

Education may have come in for criticism over other aspects of its responsibilities but it is difficult not to have sympathy for its staff and board over this matter. What it unquestioningly takes seriously is looking after the young people in its care.

The proposals it put forward to mitigate the traffic problems in the approaches to Les Nicolles may have been overkill, but the department believed they would work.

Environment’s reasoning behind the delays and foot-dragging are, from Education’s latest response, hard to take seriously.

Anyone reading the various statements will wonder whether Environment is simply out to make a point: we know best.

Education has used some of the UK’s best traffic consultants and worked alongside Environment’s own engineers to try to produce an access plan.

Yet Environment has simply released its latest proposals - good or bad - without reference to Education. That’s not just discourteous, it smacks of someone with an agenda.

As such, Education has not been able to comment on the latest proposals so parents still do not know whether their children can walk or ride safely to school.

Article posted on 3rd April, 2008 - 2.29pm

Have your say on  'Safety now second-best', comment below

eCycle - 468
Useful Numbers - 230Your Shout - 230
Guernsey Books (468) - Buy Online

One Article Comment

  1. Dave Help

    Education, and Environment, should have sorted this problem out before even the first brick was laid on the new schools, As your article stated, they knew this was the most dangerous road on the Island, and they still built a school there,
    That tells me that they don’t care about the children, they just to get thier own way.
    I believe that both parties are the biggest idiots in Government, and they should all resign because of this shambles.

Post a Comment on this Article

Your email address is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*

Disclaimer: This comment area is moderated by the Guernsey Press, which aims to create a valuable forum for the expression of views by all who have an interest in Guernsey. Contributors are expected to respect the opinions of others and all submissions may be edited. In particular, our policy is not to allow defamatory, gratuitously offensive, factually inaccurate or self-promotional statements to be posted. The moderators will not enter into e-mail correspondence about the editing of individual submissions.

Your Shout: View all recent comments. More detail on the comment icons.

If you wish to make a comment about this website, please use our feedback form.