Sunday, 21st March 2010

News from the Guernsey Press

No States funds for safety net

0648814.jpgPOLICY COUNCIL members yesterday ruled out a States-funded deposit protection scheme for Guernsey.

Jersey politicians will be asked to approve one but any such system here would have to be funded by the banking industry. There is still no indication as to what the level of protection would be and when it is likely to be introduced.

Speculation had been mounting that the two islands would work on a joint scheme, but that was quashed by yesterday’s announcement and the revelation that Jersey’s States was to be asked to approve a proposition that would guarantee every penny of residents’ savings.

Instead, the Policy Council, following an unscheduled meeting yesterday morning, has agreed to a ‘measured course of action’, which includes meeting all States members on Monday.

‘We, the Policy Council, have listened very carefully to a range of advice we have received and we have decided to put our full weight behind the speedy introduction of a scheme to protect depositors in Guernsey,’ said Chief Minister Lyndon Trott (pictured). ‘Jersey has decided on a slightly different course of action and it’s not for us to comment on the decision taken by the Jersey authorities.’

Commerce and Employment minister Carla McNulty Bauer, whose department is mandated to bring in such a scheme, said that until the findings of the Guernsey Financial Services Commission’s consultation paper with industry on the issue had been presented, it would be impossible to give an indication as to what the protection level might be, despite the UK announcing plans this week to up its protection from £35,000 to £50,000 and Ireland guaranteeing all deposits in Irish banks.

All she would confirm is that the taxpayer would not be put at risk by any scheme and that it would be funded by the industry.

A meeting has been called for Monday lunchtime so that all the issues and options concerning a scheme can be fully explained to States members by representatives of the Policy Council and the GFSC, which has been working with its Jersey counterparts to obtain support from other jurisdictions where the parent banks of local operators are based.

And despite not adopting a joint scheme, Deputy Trott said the two islands had been working closely.

‘We worked very closely with Jersey and the Guernsey Policy Council has taken its decision to further consult with Guernsey States members to make sure they are fully apprised.

‘In the last week I have spoken to Senator Frank Walker [Jersey’s Chief Minister] on more than two-dozen occasions, so any criticisms that we have not worked closely enough is dispelled by that.’

He said that by the Policy Council taking the approach it has it would assure Guernsey residents, the financial services sector, its customers and everyone who does business in Guernsey that it was a safe international finance centre.

Deputy Trott said it was likely a further announcement would be made on Monday after the meeting.

Article posted on 4th October, 2008 - 9.30am

Reader Offers
HalftimeLes Bourgs Touching Lives campaign
iTEX - Making IT easy - 468

3 Article Comments

  1. Beanjar

    What on earth are the States up to, are they happy for Guernsey to fall behind everyone else with regards to a depositers protection Scheme.
    Jersey have led the way and have offered a scheme to residents, why are Guernsey not doing the same. All small residential investors should receive some form of protection for their savings,at least up to the £35,000 previously limited in the UK, or is it that the States do not have confidence in the Banking system to offer such protection.
    Let us hope that we do not have a Company in Guernsey go to the wall and small investors lose their savings that in itself will lead to the collapse of confidence within the finance circles and could well spell the end of the Island as a finance centre.

    Report abuse

  2. Muzeek

    I totally agree with all your comments BeanJar
    It seems everyone in authority has their fingers crossed hoping this problem will just blow over.
    At this time there is nothing to support this, and in fact according to the evidence things could get much worse.
    This really is a wake up call for the States and Financial Services to make tough decisions, otherwise we could as an island be going down the proverbial plug hole, causing irreparable damage to life as we know it.

    Report abuse

  3. genius

    But why should the banks fun d this?
    But why should the taxpayer fund this?

    Who will fund this? in reality Guernsey makes its finance money from mega rich / institutions. will £ 35,000 help these? no! Placing ou money in a bank is a risk! thik about risk / reward. you banked with northern rock you got 7% interest but you were at higher risk of loosing your money then if you were with Lloyds on 4%.

    Does no one understand that with a higher return you get a higher risk.

    Want your money protected? invest in national savings!!

    In too much debt? tough luck. you made a very stupid decision when you over borrowed.

    On one hand you want the freedom to make your own choices but on the other you want the net to catch you when it is the wrong one!!

    Report abuse