A quality import goes a long way

Saturday 26th November 2011, 2:30PM GMT.

NOW here is a question for you… What is an acceptable number of overseas players for our flagship rugby side?

The acquisition of two more talented Kiwis in Malcolm Barnes and Sam Stevens, plus a new kicking three-quarter from the UK in Luke Sayer, gives Jordan Reynolds’ side an increasing chance of coming from behind to snatch another promotion.

If that happens and we are able to give Jersey a scare in the Siam, few will be complaining other than, perhaps, the family and supporters of a talented youngster emerging from the excellent Academy who finds his pathway blocked by a Blair Campbell, Nick Barton, Aussie Reynolds himself or any of the new boys from Down Under.

I am uncertain if ‘overseas’ recruitment is a thorny issue at all within the Guernsey Rugby Club membership, but for what it is worth this neutral viewer is perfectly at ease with the introduction of new recruits – as long as they are standouts and who the local boys can learn from watching and playing alongside.

Perhaps it is the fan in me that lends me to applaud any sport or club wanting to significantly better itself by looking outside the local talent pool.

It is the only way to significantly improve standards in team sport.

That said, it is not without its dangers and as Guernsey FC tick along nicely at the top of Combined Counties Division One, its management no doubt already has one eye on the future and how it guards against stagnation in terms of personal and pyramid position.

It is a point worth serious consideration because the fans, and there will be another 1,200-plus at Footes Lane this afternoon to see Hartley Wintney come to town, will not stand for a mere meandering existence.

They want to see their Guernsey team get somewhere.

The next question is what will it take to get out of the Combined Counties League altogether and get on the next rung – the Ryman Division One South and beyond?

My guess is that it will require more than the current talent pool can offer. Not much, but perhaps a new player or two.

And it is that process of recruitment, rules of engagement and ultimate acquisition which concerns me most.

As a fan – GFC is a community side and on that basis there should be no bias in anybody supporting it – I want GFC to go as far as they can within a framework that ensures the island’s best are not stifled.

Were I still a young cricketer I would have loved to have played alongside and learnt from Jeremy Frith.

Were hockey my sport I would surely want to be feeding off the brilliant Andy Whalley.

Had rugby been my game, how wonderful it would have been to have felt the assurance provided by the superbly consistent Nick Barton or, for an all too brief spell a few seasons back, the brilliant scrum half Willoughby Bloem.

Of those four only the latter did not hang around long, but Frith, Whalley and Barton have been players that their respective sports could not have done without and at the same time succeeded.

They have all been leaders by example and lifted their colleagues to newer heights.

Their sheer presence and consistency clearly proves an inspiration to others.

At some stage the Green Lions will require someone of a similar standing.

The way things are the Lions won’t be short of offers, but it is what they are offering that is most important in my mind if the club is to progress through the leagues and reach a level which sees our boys not only entering the FA Cup but threatening to make the third round.

That’s a big ask, but with a couple of footballing ‘Frithys’ and ‘Barts’ on board, then it is not a ridiculous or self-defeating scenario, and can take the biggest local game to new heights.

Of course, the Lions would have to be careful and might do well early on to set themselves some constitutional rules which prevent them getting carried away.

And those rules should ensure that every Guernsey FC player is a full-time island resident and that no player is actually paid a penny.

Remaining totally amateur is vital for the club, not least because I cannot see sponsors wanting to see their money go into players’ pockets, although that is not to say a star player cannot benefit in other ways, such as with a job and accommodation.

Rugby has managed to entice some good talent here without, as far as I am aware, handing over a note, so football should be able to do the same.

Why, I would even take a Jerseyman on board as long as the player moved lock, stock and barrel here and became a respected Sarnian as cricketer Ward Jenner achieved before career drew him back to his home island.

Guernsey sport can never be short of Friths, Bartons and Whalleys, real class acts who can take a whole sport forward by their own skills, dedication and conditioning levels.

So keep bringing in the talent I’d say.


  1. 1
    laurie carre

    i wont comment on this column, apart from saying it looks more dangerous for the future of football in gsy

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Phil

    How are players going to be attracted to GFC if they can’t be paid, and also have to be full time resident on the island?

    Does anyone else think this is getting totally out of hand? GFC is top of a poor league, nothing more, and already we have comments which would suggest that they are capable of reaching the same level as that played by a lot of semi-pros, bit without any money being paid to players.

    Deluded in the extreme I’m afraid, the only way they’ll progress to the Ryman leagues and beyond is by paying them, the local guys aren’t good enough on their own and non-locals are hardly likely to play for nothing when they could get paid elsewhere.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    GM

    Phil
    I assume they would be paid a semi-pro supplemental wage on top of being found a job which would allow them that flexibility. Pay a semi-pro £100 a week to play football on top of a tradesman’s wage and you are nearly there.
    No idea where the extra money would come from though!
    I do agree with Rob’s view that a few imports of the right disposition can benefit local sport massively. Over the years we have seen it in many sports and it does raise local standards. However they should always be a minority and it is far better if their other careers bring them here and they play here for nothing.
    I am sure that potential recruits for jobs on the island will be attracted by the opportunities available to them in football, rugby, cricket etc if they are very talented players. It may swing the balance between them choosing to come here over going somewhere else, more so than in the past, and that’s a far better route to take in my view.
    If you want an example of how to get it wrong, look at Jersey Rugby Club. There are probably only now 3 or 4 local players in the regular side and that’s even with a good domestic rugby structure which we don’t have. It’s become a rugby team which just happens to pay in Jersey and just happens to allow 3 or 4 good Jersey players to play. It just isn’t right and they’ve gone too far.
    I hope to see Guernsey FC go as far as they can using locally resident and unpaid players. If they attract a few good amateurs to move over here then I don’t see so much of an issue with that, but not professionals please.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    laurie carre

    phil. of course its getting out of hand. using rugby and cricket as an example is stupid;rugby is a one team in gsy, and cricket not much more. i would like to know what place is there for local players when you are importing players, and how would you justify local licences for these players. i did bring up some of these points earlier.gsy fc will struggle at ryman league level, so i can see constant promotion and relegation in the future.

    Report abuse

Comment

Thursday 23 February

  • Recycling and export is the way forward for waste
  • UK mail will arrive later
  • Free motoring supplement
  • Herm prepares for summer
  • Win a night at the White House

Campaigns

Voice For Victims Voice For Victims

Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.