PLANS for newly qualified drivers to display P-plates have received a mixed reaction from those responsible for teaching them. If the States agrees to the Environment Department’s proposals at the end of this month, drivers will have to show the plates for 12 months after passing their test.

But driving instructors are split on whether they are needed and if the changes would be successful.

Nick Dorey, of Cann School of Motoring, said that while their introduction could improve safety, it might be difficult to police the system.

‘There are two ways to look at it. It would be good for safety, but it’s difficult to see how those displaying them will benefit.

‘The P-plates will highlight the fact that they are inexperienced, but I’m not sure how many young people will actually display them. Most of them won’t want to, so the police will have to do a lot more stopping to make it work.

‘Our figures for accidents are no worse than other countries, so I’m not sure if it’s really needed.’

However, Karen Hudson, of the Driving School of Motoring, was very positive about the plans.

‘I think it’s a good idea. People who have just passed their test are still learning, as we all are.

‘It will give other drivers the knowledge that the other person has only just passed their test and they will give them a little more room.

‘Six months to a year, I think, is enough. You learn an awful lot in that first year driving on your own.’

The States report on P-plates follows a successful amendment by Deputy Al Brouard, which asked Environment to investigate the possibility of introducing a probationary scheme for newly qualified drivers.

Another requirement for such drivers would be that all passengers would have to wear a seat belt.

Safeway Driving School’s Andy de Guerin said he could see a use for the plates but with the standard required to pass a driving test rising, he doubted how much they were needed.

However, he felt that P-plates could deter newly qualified people from driving

irresponsibly because they would be more obvious to police.

‘Already the authorities over here can take you off the roads and make you retake your test if you are caught speeding, for example, within your first year on the roads.

‘It would mean people would be more responsible about speeding.’