A leader without any real power
Thursday 4th December 2008, 3:14PM GMT.
FIRST among equals is how the chief minister likens his role. Elected by firstly the people of his parish and secondly his peers in the States of Deliberation he is undoubtedly the leader of the island’s political democracy.
As such it is a prestigious position, worthy of due respect.
But for Deputy Lyndon Trott it is not enough to have the garlands; the job must come with the rod of genuine power.
It is clear from his speech to the CGI that after seven months in the role he feels frustrated. The lack of executive authority hampers firstly his ability to direct the government and secondly prevents him from standing tall on the national and international stage among true decision-makers.
That world stage is becoming an increasingly time-consuming and vital part of government and will continue in that vein as the UK seeks to examine the island’s place in international finance.
Some will portray the chief minister as too hungry for power, an urge the current system allows the Assembly to stifle. For those critics, a weak chief executive hamstrung by an inability to choose the team around him or her prevents abuse of power and a one-man band government.
He is thus left, as he himself complains, to force issues through by strength of personality alone.
Many deputies will say that, on the whole, he has the skill-set to achieve that very well.
Yet, as we saw at the end of the last island government, there are times when a minister falls away from the council and becomes a maverick unwilling to accept the yoke of collective responsibility and joined-up government.
And there was a time when a faction developed and it was clear a split in policy and personalities was damaging the States.
At such moments the chief minister’s weak position becomes all too evident. Once he has privately castigated the ministers and reminded them of their responsibilities he just has to hope they will come around to his way of thinking or fall on their sword.
Failing that, what is plan B?
Island Life
All about Guernsey
Ambassador of the Year 2011
History & Heritage
Visitor Information
Guernsey's government
Campaigns
Voice For Victims
Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.
Did Guernsey elect the Chief Minister? No, the Deputies did. Period. The idea in Jersey is the people should elect both the Deputies and also the Chief Minister directly. Only in that case should the role carry extra democratic powers as direct endorsement of the CM’s manifesto when running.
What’s manifest here is fracticous personality versus the committee collective of decision making. I can understand the deep frustration with committees and their all too often lowest commmon denominator or path of least resistence decision making.
But the reason given here that the CM should go walkabouts on the world stage and be able to make decisions on the hoof and come back to little ol’ Guernsey to force them down the States collective throats is such an obnoxious and frankly arrogant reasoning as to deserve the total contempt it deserves.
Frustrated with a democratic institution? Tough. Resign. Or wise up.
Report abuse
I agree JohnnyB
If the CM wants more power then they must have a public mandate. The public have no idea what our politicians stand for in Guernsey, save for the ubiquitous ‘we will do our best’. That has no bearing in the modern world. We must be able to vote for policy and direction before we give someone executive powers.
Report abuse