Backbenchers win as ‘state’ address is axed
Tuesday 9th December 2008, 1:00PM GMT.
CHIEF Minister Lyndon Trott will not deliver his ‘State of the States’ speech after the Policy Council bowed to pressure from backbenchers.
The speech, which was published in full in yesterday’s Guernsey Press after it had been emailed to all deputies, sparked considerable disquiet from the majority of the Assembly, who wanted the concept thought through more.
A Policy Council spokesman said yesterday: ‘Following the publication of the statement in today’s Guernsey Press and quotes from it in other media, ministers were unanimous in their decision that they would no longer direct the chief minister to seek to read it in the Assembly this week. The Policy Council looks forward to meaningful dialogue with the States Assembly and Constitution Committee in the new year in connection with such statements and other matters.’
The committee wrote to the chief minister after the intention to deliver the speech was announced, calling for him not to give it.
Deputy Matt Fallaize then gathered the signatures of 24 deputies who backed the committee’s stance – at that stage another three ministers were also believed to have been against the speech being made. He welcomed yesterday’s announcement that it would not go ahead.
- To read Guernsey Press stories in full click here for subscription details. Individual editions are now available online.
Island Life
All about Guernsey
Ambassador of the Year 2011
History & Heritage
Visitor Information
Guernsey's government
Campaigns
Voice For Victims
Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.
Seems a rather pyrrhic victory, on behalf of the signatories.
Report abuse
Quite the contrary.
The outcome was fully justified.
Report abuse
Ade
Do tell us how you reach the conclusion the “outcome was fully justified”.
Report abuse
Damn! I’ll have to admit to ignorance here. If a ‘pyrrhic victory’, what did the signatories lose?
Report abuse
Now, hopefully, they can stop bickering and get on with some real work – or am i dreaming?
Report abuse
A definite retrograde step by the States.
It emphasises the immaturity, lack of experience, and indeed common sense in the new too young States.
A Chief Minister should be expected to make a speech of this type. After all, it is the 21st. century and the full picture should be explained to the population.
If Guernsey wants to be recognised, by the world, as a competent jurisdiction things have to change.
Our Chief Minister, a true Guernseyman with the island’s interest at heart, is trying his best to modernise things. He should be permitted to do this without the un-necessary agressive tactics from other deputies.
Report abuse
This news is gently pleasing, nothing more. My hope that this could lead to the introduction of Freedom of Information here in Guernsey is no doubt overly optimistic.
Report abuse
BL Cumner
“Unnecessary aggressive tactics”!!!!
Report abuse