Brown speech ‘just part of the rhetoric’
Friday 6th March 2009, 2:29PM GMT.
GORDON BROWN’S speech to the US Congress in which he suggested banning tax havens was just part of the continuing rhetoric from politicians on the issue, according to a Guernsey finance expert.
Graham Parrott (pictured), a partner at Ernst and Young, said he did not think the Prime Minister knew exactly what he was talking about when he claimed the world’s savings would be safer if offshore tax havens were outlawed.
‘To some extent I think he got carried away,’ he said.
‘My only worry is that he really seemed to enjoy it. When you listened to him talking to Congress it was almost like he was playing to a response. They got up and applauded and he loved it.’
But Mr Parrott was still confident that, in the cold light of day, Guernsey would be separated from the ‘secretive’ offshore jurisdictions targeted by Mr Brown and US President Barack Obama.
‘When it comes to the G20 summit we will be distinguished from other places that are not so transparent and cooperative and where tax evasion is still not a crime,’ he said.
‘Despite Mr Brown’s comments I think it will be very difficult to be so literal and it should not happen anyway because we are addressing the issues that they are worried about.’
- To read Guernsey Press stories in full click here for subscription details. Individual editions are now available online.
Island Life
All about Guernsey
Ambassador of the Year 2011
History & Heritage
Visitor Information
Guernsey's government
Campaigns
Voice For Victims
Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.
These views are so wrong, it is not Brown but Brown and Obama. Plans are already being discussed to force the offshore islands, among others, to conform with UK tax law.
Report abuse
I imagine Gordon Brown’s speech was largely written by a team of senior civil servants and advisors who thought very carefully about the message to get over. It was a very high profile and sensitive (with the special relationship in mind) occasion and everyone will have been making sure that exactly the right message got out.
I think Mr Parrott may be being a bit fanciful in almost implying that Gordon Brown was speaking off the cuff.
It could be that what was said about tax havens was very generalised and Guernsey will, hopefully, find it is seen as high quality etc. Or it may be that there is an overriding political will that will take a broader brush to the situation.
We will have to wait and hope.
Report abuse
Have I missed out on something?????????????
Gordon Brown
***************
“How much safer would we be if the whole world came together to outlaw shadow banking systems and off-shore tax havens?”
“I want there to be no hiding place for special investment vehicles, for hedge funds or tax havens,”
Nicolas Sarkozy
*****************
“We want to put a stop to tax havens, We want results on this, with a list of tax havens and a series of consequences.”
“We’re not talking about superficial measures. We’re not talking about transitional measures. We’re talking about structural measures that need to be taken,”
Barak Obama
*************
Mr. Obama was one of the signatories of the Stop Tax Haven Abuse Act, a legislation put to Congress last year that blacklisted Jersey, Guernsey, the Isle of Man and 32 other jurisdictions.
Report abuse