Five is too low for the captain to count
Saturday 23rd May 2009, 2:30PM BST.
SEVERAL things have struck me about this week’s World Cricket League tournament.
1: The grandeur and organisational excellence of it all. Well done ICC.
2: The fantastic opportunities awaiting our developing young cricketers.
3: Who is actually in charge of the Guernsey side?
4: Where has all the experience gone from the senior island team?
Overall, it’s been a brilliant week for the number one summer game but, at the same time, it has thrown up several unanswered questions about just where the local game stands in terms of ability and world status, and what needs to be done to ensure we advance in the near future.
Although it could all go pear-shaped by losing to the amazingly inconsistent Surinamese today, the Greens should attain their original objective which is to finish in the top two and with it move up to Division Six, still one league below the crapauds who had previously been in Division Four.
Were Guernsey able to call on half the all-time Elizabeth College XI featured elsewhere in today’s edition, I would have no concerns about the island’s progress up the ICC ladder, but Dave Hearse cannot and when I look at the sides we have put out this week I see largely a bunch of cricketing novices, several of whom have yet to achieve anything of note within the local game.
That may sound harsh, but it’s true. There are signs of promise, but we are not a particularly good side.
We are chronically short of experience and, as a consequence, the pressure on the likes of Lee Savident, Jeremy Frith, Stuart Le Prevost and Gary Rich is enormous.
The absence of Ami Banerjee is particularly keenly felt.
Picking the kids is borne out of necessity and cannot be criticised, but we have seen some strange happenings this week.
One is the continued mishandling of the skipper’s batting talents.
To bat him at five or lower, as was the case against the Bahranians, the biggest threat to Guernsey’s title aspirations, was jaw-droppingly wrong.
In one-day cricket you do not bat your third most accomplished batsman and, arguably, potentially the most destructive, as low as six in games that really matter.
Because of what I see, I wonder who is in charge of this team?
Good and successful cricket sides are driven to such a position by the leadership skills of their captain, not the coach, the elite-performance director, not the team manager, or a combination of them all.
Just about everybody who watches Guernsey cricket knows it is wrong to bat the captain at five or six, so why do we continue doing it?
As for the tournament itself, it has been brilliant to see what can be done with ICC support against the backdrop of Guernsey’s ever-improving cricket facilities.
It simply emphasises where we have come in terms of world cricket and the amazing opportunities that await the island’s top players across the age-groups.
It’s just a shame that more islanders have not taken the chance to see it.
Away from the cricket, the annual island golf championships ticks along without anything thus far too exceptional, other than that of the progress of a 13-year-old who managed to reach the last 16 and give one of the tournament favourites a fright.
James Hamon (pictured) is the name and how refreshing it was to see an unfazed kid step up onto the biggest sporting stage he has come across and perform.
He showed talent and mettle and talking of guts and application, there is no emerging sportsman showing more this early summer than cricketer Dave Hooper.
There is nothing stylishly classical about his batting or physically threatening about his bowling, but sheer determination is getting the job done.
Campaigns
Voice For Victims
Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.
Before you rant check the rules of the competition. Had you done so you will find that some of your (I presume) candidates are not qualified. Others are at University or taking A levels so were not available. Who would you have included – name(s) please.
Incidentally you stated “It’s just a shame that more islanders have not taken the chance to see it.” I have been unable to find anyone who can confirm that you attended any of Guernsey’s six matches; pot & kettles come to mind.
Report abuse
Was the sports editor aware that the playing conditions include the standard ODI power play rules and that after the loss of Meades through injury after the first game the captain was the best boundary hitter after the two openers? This was surely one of the logical arguments for him batting down the order even if it was unquestionably too late in the first Bahrain game.
As far as not knowing who was in charge is concerned, surely as long as the players are aware that’s what matters. They looked a pretty good unit to me with a very good relationship between a captain who improves with every game, a coach who seems to have the utmost respect of the squad and a manager who is getting the results that his efforts over many years fully justify after being let down in Scotland and against Jersey last year.
The only downside for this observer was the appalling body language and infield antics of one so-called star player who needs to fall into line with the excellent attitudes of the rest of the squad. Otherwise he should be dropped as one weak link in the chain could derail everything.
But hey, what a week of competitive cricket. Well done to all and good luck in Singapore in August.
Report abuse