Chaos follows Esplanade crash

Tuesday 25th May 2010, 11:30AM BST.

The rider is treated at the scene. A witness said he was lucky not to fall under the bus wheels.                                                (Picture by Tom Tardif, 0974750)

The rider is treated at the scene. A witness said he was lucky not to fall under the bus wheels. (Picture by Tom Tardif, 0974750)

TAILBACKS were caused at afternoon rush hour yesterday as emergency services dealt with a motorbike crash at the South Esplanade.

According to witnesses a man on a yellow Harley-Davidson going towards Le Val des Terres tried to overtake a bus which was in the right-hand lane on the approach to the Slaughterhouse.

The 19-year-old rider was knocked off his bike, landing near the post and chain railings in the centre of the road. A metal post was bent and two rows of metal chain broken.

A witness, who did not wish to be named, said: ‘The rider tried to fit between the bus and railings and he just didn’t fit.

‘His bike bent the post and he landed on the road. He was very lucky to not go under the wheels of the bus.’

  • Read the full story in the Guernsey Press. See below for subscription details.

  • To read Guernsey Press stories in full click here for subscription details. Individual editions are now available online.

  1. 1
    rachael

    Cant quite understand this, if the bus was in the right hand lane there would be no room for anything to overtake, the buses are too big.To me it sounds like the bus was partly in the left lane as well and maybe the motorcyclist thought it was going straight on?

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Bemused

    Rachael, I agree with you, the buses are always in the middle of the road travelling along there, it’s only a matter of time before a tragic accident occurs.

    I had an argument with a bus last week that decided to pull out of the bus stop even though I was driving along the main road!!

    If we drove like they did then we’d get done for it but for some reason they think they own the roads!!!!

    MAKE THE BUSES SMALLER!!!!!

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    Confused

    I can’t wait to see the outcome of this one as it has certainly made me have to thing very hard!!

    Yes I agree with the things you are saying about the buses, they are definitely to big for these roads, but another part of me wanders whether the rider of the Harley, at just 19, was also taken a huge risk trying to overtake a bus of this size at this stage of the roadway.

    Either way I hope the rider of the bike recovers well.

    It is surely one of these “Watch This Space” times, as the saying goes!!

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Tony

    @Bemused

    Perhaps the bus driver has read the highway code and assumed you had as well?

    http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/TravelAndTransport/Highwaycode/DG_069858

    ( sections 206 ,221 ,222 ,and 223 ….. 206 and 223 seem particularly relevant to your ‘argument’ … )

    If size is such an issue why not scrap the buses altogether and give people subsidised taxi fares ? ( which would get you to and from where you want when you want …. rather than hanging around for a bus that goes nowhere near where you want twice a day … )
    Even at Guernsey prices £2million quid a year would buy a lot of taxi trips surely ??

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    blogger

    Why do motorcyclists insist on overtaking/undertaking everything on the road regardless of the road conditions.

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Martino

    Blogger…

    … because we can!

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    tim

    Martino

    Obviously not in this case!

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    Bemused

    @Tony

    Thank you for your kind advice, for one I was driving slowly and carefully as i was in the rush hour traffic queue and it states to allow larger vehicles to pull out when they are signalling to do so. this bus driver was not. he was stopped at the bus stop, outside of the line of traffic, therefore i had continued to SLOWLY follow the queue of traffic in front of me and he decided to pull out practically taking the front of my car off, when I was already alongside him, i guess, just because he can!!!

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    Martino

    tim

    Touche…

    But maybe I would have got away with it on my little 125cc scooter. I’ve never understood why people want to ride a huge hulk of a Harley in Guernsey and Vespas are so much cooler anyway…

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    Confused

    Martino,
    I think that your reply to Blogger……”because we can” is a very stupid comment, and will tend to make more motorists think that all bike riders are idiots.
    How flaming old are you?
    My guess is old enough to go back to riding your push bike.

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    Ed

    What was he doing riding a tractor through town during the rush hour anyway?

    Good job he was not towing a trailer of hay.

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    rachael

    From what i’ve been told this may not be as black and white as the eye witness account in the press would have us believe.Also apparently the motorcyclist is out of the intensive care unit now.

    Report abuse

  13. 13
    Car driver

    Oh come on, the way the motor bike riders swerve in and out of the rush hour traffic is appalling and quite frankly very dangerous!!!

    What gives them the right to undertake/overtake traffic, cut people up and skip the rush hour queues just coz they’ve got 2 wheels and not 4!!

    I might take it upon myself to drive alongside the queue of extra traffic, “just coz I can”!!!!

    Report abuse

  14. 14
    coyote

    That’s right. Blame the bus. People usually do. Blame those big nasty bus drivers. They are actually better drivers and far more polite on the roads than most island drivers. Blame the traffic. Blame the road. Blame absolutely everyone else except the suicidal idiots who rush around Guernsey desperate to show off their new toys ‘just because they can’.

    Stupid here actually thought that a Ruette Tranquille was just that; a quiet road. Stupid here thought that traffic might be slower and less determined to kill you. Stupid here got it wrong. They are just as full of ill mannered bad drivers rushing around the island ‘just because they can’.

    However, any island that crams 77,000 vehicles in 28 square miles must want its collective heads examined. There must be loads of accidents just waiting to happen but as long as you can all blame those big nasty buses, ‘just because you can’, why change anything?

    Report abuse

  15. 15
    kevin

    Confused/Blogger,
    With the ‘because we can’ comment Martino has confirmed what most drivers already realise – a good proportion of (usually but not always younger) local motorcyclists are complete idiots!

    It will take more than a few responses from irate bikers to convince me otherwise – I’ve also seen some pretty poor driving as well so I’m certainly not saying all drivers are perfect!

    Report abuse

  16. 16
    Martino

    All you Mr Angry car drivers who never take to two wheels really haven’t a clue. My original comment was somewhat flippant but I stand by it completely. That’s because those of us who prefer two wheels do so partly because our two-wheel transport (motorbikes, scooters and bicycles) give us the freedom to negotiate and pass the rush hour of lines of cars, lorries, buses that form all the traffic jams on this island.
    Cyclists and motorcyclists don’t form traffic jams. If everyone was on two wheels the traffic on this island would flow smoothly and sweetly, so why should we stay stuck behind you lot?
    No, in most cases (but clearly not in the case above) it is perfectly safe and acceptable for those on two wheels to glide past you while you gnash your teeth and curse and develop your car driver’s road rage. And if you don’t like it why not get out of your tin box and try a form of two wheel transport for yourself. You are the problem, not the solution.

    Report abuse

  17. 17
    Confused

    Hey Bemused or is it Car driver?

    Not all Motorbike riders do what you have stated.
    I certainly don’t, along with lots of the other older generation motorbike riders that I know.

    Report abuse

  18. 18
    TL

    Car driver – what gives them the right to undertake/overtake? The highway code – overtaking a queue of stationary vehicles is fine as long as you do not cause obstruction to oncoming traffic.

    Why do they skip queues? – they are doing you a favour, if they waited in line with you, you’d be even further back!

    What harm do they cause you, as long as they do not actually obstruct you or create a danger for you.

    Is your resentment sheer jealousy?

    I don’t ride a motorbike, by the way.

    Report abuse

  19. 19
    car driver.

    As I am very close to the motorbike driver. He is ok, still in hospital and the bus’s should watch where they are going!
    The buses are too big for these roads and from what I know he would not be stupid enough to put himself in danger for the sake of anything as he loved his girlfriend very much and she loves him!

    Report abuse

  20. 20
    rachael

    Coyote, this isnt about blaming the bus drivers but it is a fact these buses are too big for our roads. Having said that many of these huge lorries are also too big. Just because someone has a beautiful motorbike does not mean he is automatically a suicidal idiot showing off. There are good and bad drivers throughout the range of vehicles on our roads. Too be fair how many of us if we’re being honest can say we’ve never made a mistake on the roads and it was only sheer luck we didnt cause an accident.

    Report abuse

  21. 21
    GG

    Coyote, the buses are too big fact.

    Report abuse

  22. 22
    coyote

    Rachel and GG the buses are too big. Fact. So why doesn’t Guernsey do something about them? You have a bus service to die for and if the Island could focus on priorities it would have smaller buses and even more of them. One full bus can remove the need for a dozen or more cars from the road.

    Martino I don’t have a ‘tin box’ so I don’t clog up your ridiculous ‘thread-like’[Elizabeth George]roads and I don’t ride two wheels either. Ever tried to pick your way through Vazon of a Sunday morning.

    I go ‘green’. I use the buses or I walk, although, as I said in my last post, even the Ruette Tranquilles are a nightmare, caused by both cars and motorbikes. How many more times must I jump for my life?

    Also please will someone explain to me why an island, about 7.5 miles by 4 miles [circa 30 square miles], needs 77,000 vehicles. That’s over 2,500 vehicles per square mile. How un-eco-friendly is that?

    Report abuse

  23. 23
    Martino

    I agree with you coyote, more bus use is part of the solution too, even if the present ones are a little on the large side. I’ve got my ormer card and I use it, especially in the winter months. As you say we do have a bus service to die for.
    Oh, I also use my bicycle a lot and I agree with you about the green lanes. The 15mph limit should be the legal limit in Ruettes Tranquille and not just the recommended speed limit.

    Report abuse

  24. 24
    Dave Haslam

    Attempting to sit on the fence a little here.

    With regards to the story, I cant actually envisage what happened, so I definately think there is more to what actually happened than is being reported, but I bet this is 6 of 1 half a dozen of the other, everyone knows the dangers of guernsey buses, however methinks a 19 on a Harley wouldnt be entirely blameless either.

    However, to add to the comments above, the buses here really are too big, cycling from the upper parishes to town is fraught with danger, 90% of which is caused by buses, who seem more impatient than most car drivers when attempting to squeeze past because you are holding them up, ironically I’ll get to town before them when I (legally) sail past the queue of standing traffic on the outskirts of town.

    However the “I own the road” attitude of the drivers is more of a concern for any other road users because frankly they are driving a massive vehicle which isnt their own, and they know it. They should definately have more regard for other road users, but it seems as more animosity towards them is developed (I know many people who have had “run-ins” with buses) the worse they get.

    However i will echo my new found friends (odd that we seem to be agreeing on a lot at the moment) sentiment that if more people took to 2 wheels, whatever form, traffic on this island would be a doddle (excluding buses of course!!)

    Report abuse

  25. 25
    W H Bonney

    I have read every comment & agreed with most to be fair…

    The main arguments are that buses are too big for the roads & that Motorcyclists should take more care when on the roads…

    Why are we arguing – to be honest, both of the above are true… Buses are to big for the roads & they think they own that strip of tarmac by the terminus & they often take the law into their own hands..

    & Motorcyclists are the biggest idiots on the roads! I had one give me daggers the other day as he had no room to pull in either in front of me or behind me after overtaking 20 stationary cars & had to pull in to Lucas house to avoid being hit…

    Both buses & motorcyclists need to wise up….

    Report abuse

  26. 26
    Pete

    A bus has the right of way to pull out in front of approaching traffic, the problem is that on far to many occasions bus drives think this means they can do this when the traffic is alongside their bus or can do it when the traffic is right on to top of them.
    Motorcyclists, well thats an old chessnut. I wouldn’t want to tar them all with the same brush but quite often you get the impression they want you to knock them off their motorcycle.
    Like the one who overtook me as I was breaking for a red traffic light, cut in in front of me, took my stopping space and jammed on.
    I managed to stop about a foot from his rear wheel,he didn’t like me blowing my horn at him, so perhaps next time I wont waste the rubber of my tyres by jamming on to avoid wipeing him out.

    Report abuse

  27. 27
    GG

    I agree Pete, if a bus tries to do that I sound my horn and continue driving.

    Report abuse

  28. 28
    Scarlett

    You’ve gotta love progress.

    Life is so much easier now, whizzing from A to B in no time without a care, traffic lights, traffic jams, road rage, no parking, traffic accidents…

    we never had all these problems when we all rode round in horse and carts, that’s all I’m saying.

    Report abuse

  29. 29
    Don

    Overtaking a bus on narrow roads is always risky.Overtaking a bus at a bus stop poses enormous risks as someone may step out from behind the bus straight into your path!Rightly bus drivers have the right to pull out into the traffic stream having indicated and shown consideration for others on the road.And the same consideration for buses should come from us car drivers!And as the buses are bigger than us – if in doubt – give way!

    Report abuse

  30. 30
    Andy T

    Everyone is trying to blame the bus driver here,when really the person at fault is the biker for trying to go in between the bus and the central reservation. The bus driver would not have expected the biker to do that,so maybe when he felt the bump or heard the crash it was his/her professional driving that saved a worse calamity. Don’t give the drivers a hard rap,they have a job to do and do it well even with all the unwarrented abuse that car drivers rain down on them.

    Report abuse

  31. 31
    Rachael

    Andy, in this case dont automatically blame the motorcyclist.

    Report abuse

  32. 32
    Tony

    The buses are too big are they ?

    When I, and my kids, are all standing up on the way home with our shopping bags rolling around the aisle we think the buses are too small….

    And let us not forget that Deputy Delisle ( who is of course always right about everything!!!!! ) thinks they are too small to safely accomodate schoolchildren ….

    And everyone who feels a bus has been driven near them in an unsafe manner, you did report this to both the bus company and the police didn’t you …… ? Perhaps then something will be done about it ….

    Report abuse

  33. 33
    coyote

    Anyone who wants to rubbish the bus drivers [and it seems there are plenty of you out there happy to rubbish bus drivers] should try driving a bus yourselves, then at least you would know what you were talking about.

    A little Californian-style road courtesy on the part of Guerns wouldn’t go amiss either. Try giving way with a smile sometimes instead of ramming your oversized four-by-fours [or two-by-twos!]into every available space, causing chaos and traffic gridlock.

    Report abuse

  34. 34
    Steve-O

    Tony

    When a bus drove up the Kerb and hit my arm whilst I was walking on the pavement, I phoned up and complained, I havent heard back from them, barely got an apology. Or maybe it was my fault for causing gridlock on the pavement.

    Coyote, you are a very angry person, maybe a change of career might help.

    Report abuse

  35. 35
    cynic

    Bus drivers considerate? A few are – most drive the buses as if they own the road with scant regard for other road users – or pedestrians. Buses not too wide? There are many places where a bus coming round the corner is well over the centre line of the road due to the width and overhang which is enough to take the side out of an oncoming car – not that the bus drivers actually reduce speed in these areas or slow down to allow oncoming vehicles to mount the pavement.

    As for this incident – I can not see how any sane person would attempt what this biker is claimed to have done, unless the bus was mostly in the other lane. There wouldn’t have been enough room to even think about getting a harley through otherwise!

    Report abuse

  36. 36
    GG

    Coyote, many of us Guerns drive small vehicles, the buses should be giving way to us.

    Report abuse

Campaigns

Voice For Victims Voice For Victims

Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.