Cochrane’s example is one to follow

Saturday 15th October 2011, 2:30PM BST.

SO SAM COCHRANE has done the decent thing. He has told North sorry, but no thanks.

It’s Guernsey FC only for him, for now anyway.

I would be very surprised if other key Northerners, men such as Angus Mackay, Glyn Dyer and Alex Le Prevost, have not had similar discussions, or plan to, with manager Ross Cameron. And I expect John Peace, the new St Martin’s first-team coach, to start his reign at Blanche Pierre Lane very clear in the knowledge that all those black-and-white within GFC will be putting the island side first from now on.

What’s more, I would be amazed if Ross Allen ever plays more than the very odd game for Rangers again. The same goes for Jacques Isabelle.

Piers Ockleford, Allen and Isabelle’s Priaulx club teammate, has some serious thinking to do – go with GFC as you are good enough, would be my advice – and given their recent injuries, Bels’ Dave Rihoy and Craig Young would be better served to stay away from the Track and concentrate on Combined Counties League football.

The same advice goes to those like Scott Bougourd, Matt Loaring and Ollie McKenzie at North.

Doubling up is doing nobody lasting good and the days of a clear divide is very nearly upon us now the Green Lions have managed to find a proper base to embark on their own weekly full training sessions.

It’s not rocket science, it’s simply good sports science and now the domestic game as a whole can move on quicker without its best 20 or so players.

With clear demarcations in place everyone will be better for it, including the Priaulx League within a couple of seasons, although I do expect one more development that the seven Priaulx clubs may not like: a Green Lions reserve or academy side.

It simply has to happen and the only burning question is to where and what level it will play its football.

Many years ago, perhaps a decade, I made the suggestion that the best way to develop youngsters is to take the cream of under-18s, lump them together under some sort of banner under a quality coach, I may have even suggested they be called Athletics FC, and enter them as an eighth Priaulx League side.

Tony Blondel, then president of Vale Rec, went bananas at the suggestion. Others simply said it could not and should not happen.

‘They are our players thank you very much,’ was the party line thinking.

But, of course, they are not.

Every young footballer, just like every cricketer, hockey player, sprinter, swimmer etc., is an individual.

Sport is not their job, they do not get paid for it, they are not contracted to do anything.

Unlike school or work, they do not have to go along.

I’d say again: take the best under-18s out of youth football, get them playing a full programme of senior league and cup matches and they will achieve better results for Guernsey at Junior Muratti level.

It stands to reason they will improve as footballers at a faster rate, the Priaulx League will be a better competition for it and Guernsey FC, the new flagship and trailblazer for island football – not the league representative side playing in the Inter-League Cup – will have the ideal backup side.

The only caveat I would suggest to all this is that Guernsey FC can offer the necessary guarantee to the GFA that they can not only fund the new side, but also match what is in place for the current Green Lions first team in terms of coaching and physio support.

I’d bet every top under-18 player in Guernsey would jump at the chance to be part of the Green Lions set-up in this way and every ambitious player in the age-groups below will see it as something to aim for.

The benefits, which would also include creating openings for another two dozen youngsters who might otherwise not get to play regular youth football, far outweigh the negatives.

Key to all this, of course, is that ALL clubs have to realise and get accustomed to the ethos that each individual should have the right to do what is best for them, not a club, if they see it as beneficial to improving their prospects of maximising their amateur career in their chosen sport.

It is not about loyalty. This is not the same as a player quitting a club for another mid-season simply because he doesn’t fancy it anymore.

Individuals can still be loyal to a club, even if they no longer pull on their shirt.

A footballer is no different to, say, Lee Merrien, who no longer pulls on a GIAAC vest.

His association with and, daresay, love for GIAAC, is as strong as it ever was, only that it no longer suits him to compete for the club. He has bigger fish to fry in the world of distance running and his absence creates opportunity for others.

GIAAC know the picture and support him whole-heartedly.

Did Kristina Neves and Ian Powell turn out in the recent swimming inter-insular? No they didn’t.

Each knows that Guernsey prospects would be much greater were they to get on the blocks against Jersey, but their sights are set much higher at national and international level. They cannot do everything. It’s wholly understandable that they sat it out.

Does Tobyn Horton attempt to win any local cycling trophy? Of course not. He is aiming far higher and the Velo Club have no problem with that.

Although these are all individuals competing in individual sports, they are no different to any footballer who has the same one head, two legs and two arms.

They are all sportsmen and women who should have the common goal of wanting to get the most out of their careers.

Island football is in the early stages of a new, better, advancing landscape driven by people who know exactly what they are doing in a 21st century sporting environment.

They are not muppets these guys.

All of them are quality officials, administrators, coaches and medical men. They are one in seeing the only future which will take football forward.

So do those many hundred GFC fans who have marginal or no interest in the domestic club leagues, but see something which truly excites them.

Those people clinging onto the hope that one day hundreds are going to flock back to the touchlines to watch run-of-the-mill Priaulx League games, Jeremie Cup ties, the Malaya Cup etc. are living in cloud cuckoo land.

The football system created in 1890-odd is tired and needs a spark. Well, it has got it now whether it likes it or not.

*

ST MARTIN’S, crisis Saints only a week or so ago, are on the way back. They might not know it, but they are.

One of the most pleasing things I have read this season, second only to the sight of Sylvans making such a fantastic fist of things across the league and gaining reward for some sterling work and foresight behind the scenes, was to hear that St Martin’s had given first appearances to youth players Rob Woodhard, Ben Langlois and Joe Duquemin.

The highly-talented winger, Sam Hall, was work-tied otherwise he would have surely played too.

Saints got a 3-3 draw, they are still top of the Priaulx. There is life beyond GFC.

Good luck to John Peace and the boys who will get their chance quicker than they had expected.


  1. 1
    Gerald Largo

    Rob what are you trying to do to local football? With the exception of Guernsey FC, which in my opinion is in its honeymoon period, it is closing down around us and you are enjoying every minute of it. Do you really think that all of this is helping Guernsey football at grass roots level, if you do you are even more blinkered than I thought. Again you stand on your pedestal and spout your tunnelled visions for the way forwards when surely everyone else can see that the Guernsey football world is in turmoil and on the verge of closing down. What will happen to Guernsey FC if there are no clubs to give them players. This continues to be a selfish, narrowminded way of destroying years and years of hard work. I cant wait to see your headlines when we really have no local football, that day is approaching quicker than anyone realises. Look at the result in the NLS cup this weekend. We are the holders and we are out. Devalued all that fantastic work done over the last few years. Guernsey football is now a joke and when Guernsey FC fails or gets too big for our local born players people like you are going to have some explaining to do

    Report abuse

  2. 2
    Graham

    Get your head out of the sand my friend and you will realise that football is thriving, at St Martins we are providing football for 150 people from 14 to 54 and at mini level we are catering for 200 youngsters on a Saturday total 350 and thats just one club, closing down, grow up mate.

    Report abuse

  3. 3
    GM

    I don’t think a GFC Academy side in the Priaulx is the right way forward at all. It would be a huge disincentive to the clubs. The current situation, if properly managed, can be made to work fine, with the Priaulx clubs acting as a feeder to GFC. If the best youngsters are grabbed by a GFC Academy side, the clubs will lose all incentive to operate solid junior and ultimately minis sections. Sure, their best young players will find their way to GFC anyway, eventually, but in the meantime let them prove themselves at Priaulx level, taking advantage of the extra playing opportunities created by the best players going to GFC.

    Give it two seasons from now, and I’m convinced we will see a stronger and very competitive Priaulx, full of youngsters busting a gut to impress and get selected for GFC. The inter-insular club competitions will then also improve. Two steps backwards to take three forwards, but it will take two years.

    What would be far better than a GFC Academy side in the Priaulx is a young side in a UK national competition which guarantees say 6 to 8 games a season, something like the South West Counties ironically. Not a knockout though, as one early loss kills the development opportunity. That squad would inevitably become, in effect, a GFC Academy side because GFC are bound to take note of performances and be watching the players very closely. Very importantly, it wouldn’t alienate the clubs.

    I fully appreciate both ends of the spectrum with this debate. I don’t believe that local football clubs should see GFC as being doom and gloom for them, but at the same time the importance of the clubs as part of the overall Guernsey pyramid must be recognised. Having a strong GFC for the next 5 years is pointless if there is nothing to follow because the clubs have been suppressed and disincentivised. But it really doesn’t need to be like that at all.

    Report abuse

  4. 4
    Blue

    Gerald/Graham

    I can see both sides of your arguments.

    I coach at North and we too have a thriving club which caters for all ages and abilities.

    My main concern when GFC started was what was going to happen to ‘our’ leagues. There was always going to be a breaking point with players loyalties and how thinly they could spread themselves.

    As i’ve said in a previous forum to Laurie Carre, the new development of talent is going to take a bit of time to shine through. It’s a bit of a learning process for everybody. We ‘local’ coaches are not loosing heart and still enjoy what we can do for our future footballers.

    Gerald

    Try not to take too much notice of Mr Batiste. His opinion is not relevant and his knowledge of the local game taday is left wanting. I’ve given up reading his column now as it just used to wind me up. Oh for another Rex Bennent!

    Report abuse

  5. 5
    Gerald Largo

    Graham if that is the case you lot at St Martins should start singing from the same hymn sheet. Some of the hierarchy at your club have told me what Guernsey FC are doing to your sides and obviously do not have the same views as you. I was not talking about all of the youngsters that you are personally providing to Guernsey football I was talking about the mess that is left behind this damn project. Me grow up a man of your years and experience should be able to see what this is doing and where it is going

    Report abuse

  6. 6
    Graham

    My opinions on Guernsey F C are not for publication, hovever, I stand my ground on the comments that football is not in decline, I quoted 350 involved at St Martins and I am sure tht 5 other Priaulx clubs could quote the same, up at St Martins we are not ‘us lot’ as you say indeed we are very experienced and hard working people who have served in many areas of the local game and for many years, in my case 40.

    Well said ‘Blue’ but unfortunately there will never be another Rex Bennett which is the reason that I no longer read the sport pages to any great degree as I am completely fed up with the obvious and blatent bias shown to a certain part of the local football scene by the press

    Report abuse

  7. 7
    Sage

    Its a question of balance.
    Rob is right to sing the praises of Guernsey FC. Its brilliantly run and each one of their home games attracts more spectators than most Priaulx teams get all season. The public are behind it and with so much local support the Press is right to five it as much profile and support as it does.
    But what Rob must not forget is that Guernsey FC is the top of our local pyramid. Without the clubs there is no pyramid, just a spike. With no pyramid there is no process for producing good young footballers, in which case the future production line of players for Guernsey FC would shrink or dry up. The two have to co-exist. With that in mind, it would help far more if Rob was to recognise that alienating the clubs is just not in the interests of the local game as a whole. 16 players are involved with Guernsey FC each week, but literally a thousand or more play every locally. It cannot ever be just about an elite of 16 or even 32 players.
    A sense of balance is all that’s required and all will be fine. Naïve or unhelpful articles will help to scupper that.
    Rob’s heart is in the right place but a more even-handed approach is vital. Rob – you don’t have to be deliberately controversial all the time. You will gain more respect or regain more respect if you aren’t so deliberately controversial.

    Report abuse

  8. 8
    laurie carre

    many valid comments,but do we have to have things like grow up ect, we are all entittled to our opinions, and once again proper names would be good.what are people scared of.guernsey football will die, unless real gsy football people act soon, and with that gsy fc will in not to many years run out of new players and will suffer.rob is not and never will be a football reporter.he is an athletics and cricket man, with gsy fc and before them tics rob has an easy job, just one team to report on,and i do wish he would cease running down many people who believe in times gone by, yes things must progress,but not to the detriment of all local football.SAGE.couldnt agree more.GM. i do hope you are right about 2 yrs,but after watching the u21 recently, i have my doubts.

    Report abuse

  9. 9
    GM

    Laurie
    I don’t think you should read too much into one-off U21 matches. The measurement of depth has to be far wider than that.

    Report abuse

  10. 10
    laurie carre

    gm. i hope you are right, we will have to wait and see

    Report abuse

  11. 11
    Graham Skuse

    Hi Laurie,

    You have a point which I agree with unfortunately we do not have the right people heading the various sides, I forsee a few more problems in the not to distant future, I also agree that some strange names appear to write on this forum, what a pity they do not have the bottle to give us a clue as to who they are, my name is Graham Richard Skuse and I have no bother in using it for my opinions, pity about the cowards who hide

    Report abuse

  12. 12
    Gerald Largo

    I too hope you are right GM in fact I pray you are right. I just see a time where GFC climb to a place where we have no players good enough to play for them and the distruction trail that is left in their wake may be so awful that it is irreparable. GFC has been up and running for around 3 months and the standard of local football, inter island football and representative football has drastically dropped, I mean even more than I imagined or predicted. Can we leave it 2 years if this much damage has been caused in 3 months? Good luck to GFC but those of you who have only become football supporters in Guernsey since GFC need to understand that this gamble with our beloved local game is not right. GFC provides football for the elite, if they are fit and if not some of the less talented players get a chance. The Islands clubs provide football for all and have to do so if they wish to be an FA Chartered Club. The FA took them there when Mark Le Tissier was in control, it cost thousands of pounds to acheive this status including all of the coaches that went through their training courses. It was all about money, funds from the training courses, funds from the bookings. The FA took their eye off the ball and that is where our local football went wrong. When they started fining players for bookings and disciplinary issues they were taking part of their families wages. What right did the FA have to do this? I would understand if the players were paid to play but as far as I know none are/were. Some players just could not afford to play football in case they got fined in any way. Even a mistake by a referee, not intentional, maybe mistaken identity, a human error, costs a player and as the fines build up they became debtors to the Clubs who then had the option to post them as debtors so they could not play. What was that all about in an amateur sport? I am confused and astounded at where we find ourselves today and I really do believe that it is not all GFCs doing it has been coming for a long time.

    Report abuse

Campaigns

Voice For Victims Voice For Victims

Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.