A forlorn wish for a fair ballot based on policy not personality
Saturday 1st December 2012, 10:00AM GMT.
Sark voters go to the polls at a previous election.
SARK goes to the polls in less than a fortnight, with electors having 14 votes each and 22 candidates from which to choose.
The election is on Wednesday 12 December and, as has already been reported, two sitting conseillers will not be defending their seats and so at least a couple of ‘new’ faces will be present when the legislature meets in January.
Paul Armorgie and Helen Magell have decided against seeking another four-year term and so there will be vacancies on the Emergency Services, Medical and Tourism committees in respect of Conseiller Armorgie and on Education (where she was chairman) and the Douzaine in respect of Conseiller Magell.
Those vacancies, and others which may arise as a result of the election, will be filled at a special sitting of Chief Pleas early in January in a process that, as I have remarked before, is so seriously flawed and open to abuse as to almost defy belief.
To summarise my criticism, the number of votes cast in elections for several committees has exceeded the number available to conseillers because voting is done by show of hands and there is no check on the number of candidates members vote for. If there are two vacancies on a committee and four candidates then the total votes cast should not exceed two times the number of conseillers – 28 conseillers equals 56 votes – yet after both the 2008 and 2010 elections there were discrepancies. Two vacancies should equal two votes and not three votes, as has certainly happened in the past.
There is only one fair process and that is by way of secret ballot with the conseillers writing down on voting slips a number of names not exceeding the number of vacancies. These are then collected, scrutinised and counted in a system that is not open to abuse.
In the meantime, the electorate await the manifestoes or election statements from those candidates who choose to send them out. I know it’s a bit of a forlorn hope, but it would be nice if this election was fought on policies rather than personalities. However, given what I am told has already appeared on social networking websites (I wouldn’t know how to access one), I am not holding my breath.
These Neanderthal refugees from Charles Darwin’s waiting room – from both sides of the political divide that exists here – really ought to be ashamed of their petty name calling, not to mention personal insults. At a time when Sark is in desperate need of clear policies to see this community through some difficult and often unpleasant times, elections and what goes with them should at least be civilised.
A last word for now about the election. It is more than four years since the main provisions of the Reform Law were enacted and we still do not have any machinery for a postal vote. Less than 48 hours before the polls open, I have a medical appointment away from Sark that I must keep. I hope I can get back here in time but, thanks to a legislature that has spent much of the last four years enacting legislation to stop people doing things, if I don’t then I lose my right to vote.
*
On a much brighter note and despite some appalling weather, the annual Christmas sale and lunch in aid of the Professor Saint Medical Trust was held at the Island Hall last Saturday and raised a few pounds short of £1,000.
The lunch was attended by more than 40 Sark residents and featured traditional Christmas food. Coming hard on the heels of the Cheque Presentation Night and what seem to be ever-increasing requests for charitable donations, the £965 to help subsidise the cost of prescribed medication was a superb sum in what for many are difficult times indeed.
* The email address for comment is fallesark@sark.net.
- To read Guernsey Press stories in full click here for subscription details. Individual editions are now available online.
Campaigns
Voice For Victims
Voice for Victims is a campaign aimed at promoting the rights of those affected by child sexual abuse.
More bile & invective! Why post such tripe.
Note – Neanderthal man had a larger brain case than modern humans and was never alluded to by Darwin in his books.
Report abuse
‘Neanderthal man had a larger brain case…’
It’s the quality of the books in the bookcase, not the size of the bookcase that counts.
Report abuse
Phil:
Really, you should know better than this. You can’t say…
“I wouldn’t know how to access [social media]”
and then comment …
“Neanderthal refugees from Charles Darwin’s waiting room – from both sides of the political divide that exists here – really ought to be ashamed of their petty name calling, not to mention personal insults.”
Come and join the robust online debate – it’s where the people and opinions that make up the genuinely free press hang out these days.
Report abuse
Gosh, Phil, you are an idealist and romantic.
An election based on policy rather then personality would be a unique event for the entire UK in recent times!
Such is the marvel of a client “democracy” where votes are purchased with fairy money – in the hope that 5 years is long enough for memories to fade.
Report abuse
@Alan J
Well said, ‘Free Speech’ is very, very slowly being erroded, on Sark as well as in the Big Outside World by the current day ‘Political Correctness’ stance that most Governments are adopting, in my opinion it’s complete balderdash!
But on Sark it is even more so, with the SNL spewing weekly nonsense and NOT being brought to account for any of it??
And should one make a negative remark re: SEM/SNL and owners and manager/editor, one can expect a writ of some sought or other, or perhaps the Guernsey Police being called in to investigate. Making editorial mileage out of every incident and individuals to suit the purpose which is????
My memories of Sark was of natural beauty, peace and tranquility, a step back in time and was that so wrong? I don’t think so. The Sark Residents at that time were completely at ease with themselves and their neighbours and visitors to the Island. Any dispute that arose was sorted out at the Kitchen Table so to speak.
But now it’s Money, Money and MORE Money.
I for one will never return to Sark whilst certain indiviuals walk the roads there.
Report abuse
It really is time you hung your hat up Phil
Report abuse
Below is a comment from http://www.ebenezerlepage.blogspot.com.The thing about truth is that it reads well, compared to the above it shines.
‘As a counterpoint just watched the latest episode of Isand Parish. I have always enjoyed this series – its probably the best advert for Sark, (who most people in the UK didn’t even know existed,) that could be imagined.
Even allowing for the series avoidance of political shenanigans, vineyards, SNL and small community feuding, due to its focus, it shows just why Sark is so special – as it has for other islands. Lawless island – bah humbug.
My recordings of the episodes will be transferred to DVD and will be enjoyed for many years to come.
Excluding the SNL and the BBs invasion – Sark you are so lucky and have such a very precious island and way of life. Choose well on the 12th.’
Report abuse